**CLUNY IS NOW CLOSED**
When I first stepped foot in Argentina, Cluny was the HOTNESS. All the rave. The cool place to weekend Palermo-it-up. But, at a whopping minimum 30 pesos per person, my cheap Study Abroad ass opted to go down the street to the then LAID back (ahem) Mark’s Deli for a delicious SEVEN peso sandwich or salad. Times have changed, prices have tripled, none of my Study Abroad clothes fit me anymore, and Mark’s is now filled with tan men in deep V-neck shirts/wooden necklaces. After many years with intentions to check out this spot, it finally came the time to experience the wonders of Cluny (El Salvador 4618).
Things started off on the wrong foot. Keen to sit outside, to enjoy the last few warm days and take advantage of prime photo lighting, I asked how long it would take to wait for a table in the patio. After asking two servers, I finally was directed to a man in a track suit, who looked as if he was about to work out, power walking around Plaza Armenia. Our conversation went something like this (in Spanish):
Me: Do you know how long the wait would be for 2 people to sit outside?
Track Suit Manager: No.
Me: Maybe just approximate?
Track Suit Manager: When the people are finished.
Me: Ummm OK??
Track Suit Manager: Look, you can walk around and see what course people are on if you want. But our kitchen closes in 30 minutes, so you’ll have to order before then.
Me: Fine, just a table for two inside. How about by the window?
Track Suit Manager: No, that’s reserved.
Me: OK, just anywhere (RAYOS, I walked to my dark table in defeat).
After sitting down, it took about another 20 minutes for someone to acknowledge our existence. Finally, a server came by, took the order, then returned after 10 minutes to ask the order again. *I should note by this time about 3 tables cleared from outside, the reservation table by the window still did not show, and in all my passive aggressive glory, I kept a big smile and did not ask to move tables.
OK most important part… Cluny offers two types of lunch options: regular menu or specials menu (choose from 5 different main courses). The special menu has the option to include appetizer, dessert, drink and has different prices depending on which combo is chosen. I opted for the special lunch special of Appetizer + Entree + Glass of Wine which was around AR$80. Appetizers were chosen: Gazpacho & Quiche (guess who ordered the buttery, cheesy, least healthy option?).
The gazpacho came out cold, so I bitched and demanded it be taken back to the kitchen. Then they explained to me that gazpacho was SUPPOSED to be cold. Yeah right, I’m not falling for that Argie chamuyo (not really, but I did witness this scenario happen once in a restaurant where a woman FLIPPED HER SHIT and demanded hot gazpacho). I digress.. the soup was very watery and weirdly spicy. Not the delicious kind of firey spiciness, but the more sharp, sour kind that stabs the back of your throat.Quiche, on the other hand, was quite good… nice portion, buttery, cheesy, oily – just how I like it (and my men).
For the main course I ordered the pan seared trout on top of a crispy risotto cake. They even brought out a fun little utensil to easily peel off the skin in one swoop… Definitely the highlight of the meal. It’s very easy to mess up risotto, but this was creamy, cooked to perfection and had a nice layer of crisp to it. The fish also, perfectly cooked, full of flavors. All of this was served on top of some sour cream type sauce that wasn’t necessary.My celiac-diseased lunch-mate ordered the chicken, one of the only things the server assured had no traces of wheat. It was served with a flan maiz and drizzled with a sweet balsamic reduction. Chicken wasn’t great, seemed poor quality throw away pieces with little meat, but the sides delish. Just wish it had more corn flan + sauce.
So I finally went to Cluny – HOORAH! While it is a beautiful atmosphere with an interesting menu, I don’t think I’ll be back soon. In my opinion, just doesn’t live up to the hype.
First 3 Photo Creditz: In Spirits
Daniel says
Expensive and bad service, enough.
anonymous says
cold*
anonymous says
gazpacho is supposed to be cool! they weren’t lying to you, google it.
Anon. says
It’s too bad you waited so long to go. Although still good, was really very good a couple years ago. We used to go often. You should know that by now! ;) If trusted sources tell you it’s good, go NOW! Experience tell us that it will inevitably go down hill. :(
Carly says
I think you had a bad experience. I have been to Cluny several times, twice for lunch and maybe 4 times for dinner and I think it lives up to it´s rep. FYI it is my parent´s favourite restaurant here in BA and they are some fussy first-worlders. The service is over-the-top but always exceptional, I have never seen anyone working there who is not super well dressed (tracksuit, en serio?!) and the food always hits the mark: salmon, prawn risotto, the duck, risotto… all great in my opinion.
It is expensive and I would not usually go there for dinner on a Saturday night, but when someone else is paying I am there in a flash. I think you should try it again!
bebero says
Hey! I just wanted to ask if your name is Razalba for real, because that’s exactly how English speakers pronounce my name (Italian) !
razalba says
HA… I wish , pretty awesome name. It’s my last name backwards + BA
Hamish says
I had the inverse experience when I went, lovely service, very average, expensive food. 100% agree that it doesn’t live up to the hype.
GK says
I recall they had a pretty outstanding bread basket…
razalba says
Yes, I do agree… bread basket was a highlight.
Angela says
I went there twice back in 2008 probably. The first time was great. The second was awful (both in terms of service and food). I went again in 2009 hoping that I’d just been there on an off night. Nope. Awful again. You’re so right. It doesn’t live up to the hype.
TL says
But gazpacho is supposed to be cold! And raw! You were being sarcastic, right? I can’t tell! Sounds not too bad a place, actually, with the service as to be expected in most places… Still, I’ve been here for three years (two years just around the corner from Plaza Armenia even!) and I’ve never paid a second of attention to that place!!
razalba says
me sarcastic? never……
My expectations for service here is already very low, but sometimes I’m still surprised in the more expensive/touristy places when the service is extra bad.